Fake Politics by Jason Bisnoff

Fake Politics by Jason Bisnoff

Author:Jason Bisnoff
Language: eng
Format: epub
ISBN: 9781510705487
Publisher: Skyhorse
Published: 2019-04-24


[A]nti-smoking activists and tobacco industry officials alike agree that the Food and Drug Administration rules announced yesterday amount to a watershed moment in which the federal government, after decades of false starts, conflict and delay, has finally chosen to move decisively to restrict a product that health experts consider America’s primary cause of preventable disease and death.37

Matthew Myers, general counsel for the Center for Tobacco-Free Children, told the Post, “Thirty-two years after the surgeon general’s first report, the government has finally replaced rhetoric with substance.”38

As would be the case whenever regulations began to appear, the NSA was on the case. NSA President Thomas Humber was quoted in the same story as saying, “It is the epitome of the slippery slope . . . Someone smart figured out that this is a first acceptable step. This is not where [FDA Commissioner] David Kessler wishes to stop.”39

The counter campaign from the industry against these rules came on all fronts. From a lawsuit in North Carolina Federal Court to efforts to impact the voting polls to Washington, DC, where they made huge financial investments, they were a force to be reckoned with. However, time had eroded their hold. Frankel wrote, “But even in Congress, their dominance is now in dispute. Industry lobbyists privately concede they are uncertain whether they can muster the votes to overturn or preempt the FDA, and anti-tobacco activists are expressing new confidence.”40

The tides were turning and momentum was at the backs of anti-smoking advocates by the fall of 1997. On September 21, Tom Kuntz wrote about the still fervent pro-smoking “Resistance” in the New York Times. It came as no surprise that “defenders of smoking aren’t taking things lying down.” And the example he used of this movement, you guessed it, was the National Smokers Alliance. He carefully ascribed them as “claiming 3 million members” while not shying away from saying that the group “gets much of its financial support from tobacco companies.”41

Kuntz used the words from the NSA’s own newsletters, namely The NSA Voice and The Resistance, to ascribe an ideology to those fighting for the right to smoke. In the inaugural issue of the latter publication, the term resistance, in that case resisting laws against smoking, was compared to the French resistance groups during World War II when the country was occupied by the Nazi Party: “It has happened in many other countries, in many other circumstances and under many other names, but the Resistance has always been the last line of defense against those who would impose their will on a minority.”42

They cited instances where smoking bans were disobeyed as brave stands against tyranny by referencing a smoking law in Toronto that local businesses refused to enforce, instead eating sizable fines upwards of a few thousand dollars.

They knew their enemy well and in The NSA Voice they went after scientific findings opposite to their stance and also told horror stories of smoking bans reducing great municipalities to barren wastelands. For that they cited Mesa, Arizona, where a smoking ban was in place in a majority of public places.



Download



Copyright Disclaimer:
This site does not store any files on its server. We only index and link to content provided by other sites. Please contact the content providers to delete copyright contents if any and email us, we'll remove relevant links or contents immediately.